Памятки юриста — страницы
2026-10-19 12:00 Памятки: Россия

Apply to reduce a contractual penalty

Key point. A debtor organisation must itself request reduction and establish grounds. A large amount or lack of funds alone does not demonstrate manifest disproportionality. For a business contractual penalty the law requires exceptional circumstances and proof that recovery could give the creditor an unjustified benefit.

When this guide helps

Debtor organisation in ordinary arbitrazh claim proceedings; first instance considers a contractual penalty; documents support manifest disproportionality and possible unjustified benefit.

When you need different advice

Excludes principal, ordinary borrowing interest, Article 395 interest, IP compensation and disputes confined to absence of breach. The selected penalty is unpaid and the case is in first instance. A high figure gives no automatic reduction; individual calculation requires case materials.

What the full memo contains

  • step-by-step actions (4)
  • documents to prepare
  • questions for a lawyer
  • sources: ГК РФ, часть первая; АПК РФ; Пленум ВС РФ от 24.03.2016 № 7

Buy PDF · 149 ₽

Free in the Yurpomoshch app

All memos · Ask a lawyer

Россия · RU-B017 · Current as of 19.10.2026. Lawyer Alexander Lebedev, 19 years of practice.