Key point. If the same contractual penalty was properly paid in full, object to paying it again. Prove performance of that exact obligation: an unexecuted payment order or unclear allocation is insufficient.
When this guide helps
Same contractual penalty properly paid in full, allocation proved; repeated demand without new deduction. Other breaches not admitted. Registered platform, repeated demand after 1 October 2026.
When you need different advice
Excludes other penalties, partial payments, unexecuted orders, disputed allocation and challenge to first charge’s basis. New deduction, penalty reduction, recovery and litigation separate.
What the full memo contains
- step-by-step actions (4)
- documents to prepare
- questions for a lawyer
- sources: ГК РФ, АПК РФ, Федеральный закон от 31.07.2025 № 289-ФЗ: выбранные нормы
Россия · RU-B184 · Current as of 19.10.2026. Lawyer Alexander Lebedev, 19 years of practice.